A Detailed Comparison: 5 Best Data Maturity Models

You can’t measure progress without first choosing a lens. And in data, that lens is the maturity model you adopt.

‍

But every lens shows you something different.

‍

Some models emphasize governance. Others focus on adoption, architecture, or analytics. None agree on what “mature” looks like. Which means the same data team could be classified as “Developing” under one framework and “Advanced” under another, with no actual change in capability.

‍

This is the real friction point for most organizations; not the need for assessment, but the cost of choosing the wrong one. Because once you commit, you’re investing time, energy, and political capital in a structure that will shape how decisions get made. And if that structure doesn’t match your priorities, it introduces drag where you were trying to create momentum.

‍

This guide exists to solve that. We break down the five most commonly used data maturity frameworks—5X’s Data & AI Maturity Assessment, DCAM, DAMA, IBM, Gartner, and TDWI. What each model is built for. Where it performs. When it misleads. And how to know which one’s actually worth your time.

What makes a data maturity model useful?

A data maturity model guides how organizations manage and use data, defining stages from basic collection to enterprise-wide insights. But many models fall short.

‍

Some frameworks are too theoretical, listing frameworks and principles without clarity on implementation. Others apply rigid structures that don’t scale across industries or company sizes. That confusion sinks data maturity initiatives before they start.

‍

A strong model enables three key actions:

‍

• Assess clearly: Pinpoint your current maturity and benchmark it
• Prioritize effectively: Highlight gaps that matter for your goals depending upon your org size
• Act confidently: Offer precise steps to improve

That said, let’s look at the most commonly used data maturity models today and then find out how to choose the right one for your use case.

5 Best data maturity models in 2025

There’s no shortage of data maturity models, but choosing the right one depends on your goals, industry, and internal structure. Some are highly detailed, built for regulated enterprises. Others focus on analytics and business outcomes. Here's a breakdown of the most widely used models in 2025:

‍

1. 5X Maturity Framework

Most data maturity models are academic, slow, and disconnected from execution. The 5X Data and AI Maturity Framework is different. It is a pragmatic five-stage model—Nascent, Developing, Operational, Advanced, and Leading—designed to help companies assess and accelerate their data and AI journey across six mission-critical domains: data infrastructure, data quality and modeling, BI, governance, predictive analytics, and AI readiness.

‍

The 5X Data and AI Maturity Framework is designed for enterprise and SME leaders who need a structured, actionable view of where their organization stands and a direct path to improvement.

‍

It defines five maturity levels—Nascent, Developing, Operational, Advanced, and Leading—across six critical domains: infrastructure, modeling and data quality, BI, governance, predictive analytics, and AI readiness. 

‍

But unlike academic frameworks like DCAM or DAMA, which often require months of diagnostic effort and yield limited executional value, 5X’s model is built for implementation.

‍

Key advantages:

‍

• Fast, structured insight: Complete the assessment in under 10 minutes
• Backed by industry standards: Built using best-practice frameworks, adapted for execution
• Benchmark-ready: Compare your org against peers in your industry and size
• Actionable output: Get clear, strategic recommendations on what to prioritize next
• Cross-functional relevance: Built for data leaders, business owners, and executive teams alike.

This is a simple way to bring structure to your data strategy and align teams around a clear view of where you are, and where you’re going.

‍

2. DCAM (Data Management Capability Assessment Model)

Developed by the EDM Council, DCAM is built for large enterprises that need structure and rigor in how they manage data. It’s especially popular in financial services, where data must meet strict regulatory and operational standards. 

‍

The model spans eight capability areas including architecture, metadata, and control frameworks. It's frequently used to support internal audits and external compliance checks, offering a structured path to regulatory readiness.

‍

What we like:

‍

• Built-in alignment with regulatory and compliance frameworks
• Clear capability definitions and scoring
• Widely adopted in finance, giving teams a peer-aligned reference point

Watch out if:

‍

• You're a fast-moving org without dedicated data governance staff
• You need guidance beyond governance—DCAM doesn't focus on AI, analytics, or operational use cases

3. DAMA-DMBOK (Data Management Body of Knowledge)

The DAMA-DMBOK framework is an encyclopedic reference for data management. It defines 11 knowledge areas such as data modeling, integration, and metadata, offering a common language and deep theoretical grounding for data teams.

‍

It’s not a step-by-step roadmap, but rather a knowledge base. It’s well-suited for orgs that are formalizing their data programs and want to establish clear roles, processes, and documentation standards.

‍

What we like:

‍

• Rich and complete framework with long-term strategic value
• Excellent for building foundational documentation and operating models
• Supports education and training for maturing data teams

Watch out if:

‍

• You’re looking for executional guidance—DAMA doesn’t tell you what to build or prioritize
• Smaller orgs may find it too abstract without dedicated governance leadership

4. Gartner Data and Analytics Maturity Score

Gartner’s Data & Analytics Maturity Score is designed for business-first strategy alignment. It defines five maturity levels—starting from descriptive analytics and evolving to autonomous decision-making—giving CDAOs and data leaders a transformation blueprint that ties data to outcomes.

‍

It’s best for exec teams building a cross-functional data strategy and looking to measure impact as capabilities evolve.

‍

What we like:

‍

• Accessible to non-technical execs and business leads
• Ties analytics maturity directly to business value
• Popular benchmark across industries for transformation strategy

Watch out if:

‍

• You’re seeking technical depth—Gartner doesn’t go deep on architecture or data engineering
• It can be too high-level for teams looking for concrete next steps

5. TDWI Analytics Maturity Model

The TDWI Analytics Maturity Model offers a practical lens on analytics maturity. It assesses six dimensions including data management, infrastructure, and organizational support. It’s well-suited for IT and BI teams who want to benchmark capabilities and evolve toward scalable, governed analytics environments.

‍

It strikes a balance between governance, enablement, and operationalization without being overly theoretical.

‍

What we like:

‍

• Realistic, pragmatic assessment for mid-to-large orgs
• Great for BI and analytics leads building internal capability roadmaps
• Provides tactical recommendations aligned with business functions

Watch out if:

‍

• You’re looking for deep governance or AI-readiness coverage—it stays analytics-focused
• It may under-serve highly regulated sectors needing audit-grade frameworks

How to choose the right data maturity model

Choosing a data maturity model might seem like a technical decision. But in practice, it’s a strategic one. The framework you pick will shape how your teams prioritize investments, measure progress, and report outcomes. 

‍

“For every company spending two years and a million dollars trying to set up the perfect data stack, there is one using a Postgres replica to answer their business critical questions today. Don't let all the architecture diagrams confuse you. Most companies I have either worked with or talked to have built things in an iterative way. This also means building up your data maturity slowly rather than trying to use the newest tools you've read about.”

~ Benjamin Rogojan, Fractional Head of Data

‍

Before committing to any model, ask yourself:

‍

• What stage is your organization at today?
  Are you just getting started with basic dashboards and data quality? Or are you already investing in AI and looking to scale it?
  
• How complex is your data environment?
  A single-source SaaS company doesn’t need the same framework as a multi-cloud, global enterprise with fragmented systems.
  
• What’s your goal for the next 12 months?
  Are you focused on compliance and enterprise governance? Or on enabling real-time decision-making across teams?
  
• How much time and headcount can you realistically invest in this?
  Some models require a dedicated data office to implement. Others allow business and engineering teams to lead the change together.
  
• Is the framework flexible enough to evolve with you?
  Most companies won’t stay in one stage forever. Your model should help you grow without forcing a complete reset.

That’s why 5X takes a model-agnostic approach. Instead of following one framework, it checks your data maturity across six key areas and scores you across five clear levels. 

‍

‍

Why most companies struggle to choose the best data maturity model

87 percent of businesses say poor data quality holds back their digital goals. And often, that problem persists not because the solution is unknown, but because the first step is never made clear.

‍

Most organizations want to improve how they manage and use data. The natural starting point is to choose a maturity model that can guide the process.

‍

So what’s getting in the way? Here are the most common reasons teams get stuck:

1. The models use different labels

One model might call your current setup "Level 1," another says "Initial," and a third puts you somewhere else entirely. These levels are not standardized, so it becomes difficult to compare or track progress with confidence.

2. The instructions are too broad

Most models describe what the end state looks like, but they do not offer clear steps to get there. Teams are left trying to guess which tools to adopt, what processes to set up, or what capabilities to build.

3. The focus is not always relevant

Some models are heavily centered on governance or policy. That might make sense for a financial institution, but it is less helpful for a company focused on analytics, growth, or customer experience.

4. They assume large, specialized teams

Many models are built with enterprises in mind. They expect dedicated roles like data stewards, governance leads, or a full-time data strategy office. If you are a mid-sized company, you likely do not have that kind of structure.

‍

All of this creates confusion. Instead of taking action, teams end up stuck in meetings, comparing notes, building internal spreadsheets, and revisiting the same conversations again and again.

Why measuring data trust matters in maturity assessments

Almost every role in the organization interacts with data for decision-making. Governance ensures that this data is trustworthy and aligned with our business goals.
‍‍~ McKinley Hyden, Director of Data Value and Strategy at the Financial Times
How Financial Times Built Data Capabilities Worth £3.2M (and counting!)

‍

Maturity models help you map your progress across tools, governance, and data and AI readiness. But without knowing how trustworthy your data actually is, those scores can be misleading.

‍

Data trust doesn’t need its own score; it should show up in how your systems and teams actually work. That’s exactly how the 5X Data & AI Maturity Assessment is designed.

‍

Instead of pulling out “trust” as a standalone metric, the assessment weaves it into how you score across core areas like modeling, governance, and quality. You’ll answer 15 quick questions covering everything from documentation practices to standardization and cross-team alignment. Each response contributes to your overall maturity tier—from Nascent to Leading.

‍

By the end, you will see a breakdown of where your strengths lie, where your blind spots are, and what you can do next to improve how your organization uses and manages data.

What are the categories of data maturity?

‍

Most data maturity models follow a five-stage structure. These stages reflect how an organization evolves in managing and using data across teams.

1. Nascent

Data is scattered or incomplete. Reporting is done manually, often in spreadsheets. There's little consistency or trust in the numbers. A small business tracking sales in Excel with no centralized system is a good example.

2. Developing

Some systems are connected, and basic reporting tools like dashboards are in use. Definitions may vary across teams, and there’s no clear ownership. A growing SaaS company using Google Analytics and a CRM but struggling with data quality fits here.

3. Operational

Data is more reliable and regularly used for decision-making. Governance processes are forming, and teams start using centralized dashboards. Think of a retail brand that consolidates store-level data to track performance and manage inventory.

4. Advanced

Predictive models and automation begin to support operations. Data quality is high, ownership is defined, and insights are used proactively. A logistics company forecasting demand based on past patterns would likely be here.

5. Leading

Data drives the business in real time. AI is embedded in key workflows, and the organization adapts quickly based on data signals. This is where companies like Amazon and Netflix operate; using data to customize experiences or optimize supply chains on the fly.

The 5X model follows this five-tier structure but goes further. It measures maturity across six dimensions like infrastructure, governance, and AI. Then it gives you a clear path forward based on where you are and what matters most to your business.

Choose a model that helps you take action

A good data maturity model should do more than label your current state. It should guide you with clear steps, align with your business goals, and help you move faster.

‍

Most frameworks help assess where you are, but they stop short of showing how to improve. That’s where the 5X maturity model stands out. It benchmarks your organization across six core areas—including infrastructure, quality, governance, and AI—and places you in one of five clear tiers. Then it shows exactly what to work on next, with guidance tailored to your team’s structure and goals.

‍

If you’re tired of theoretical models that create more confusion than clarity, the 5X model offers a faster, more actionable alternative.